Update On The Newtown Traffic Problems

January 26, 2012

A number of people have asked me what happened at the Petitions Committee when Carl Sargeant, the Minister with responsible for Transport came to give evidence the other day. I have listed below the relevant part of the transcript from the National Assembly’s Website.

 

The National Assembly for Wales

The Petitions Committee – Tuesday, 10 January 2012

 

205]       Russell George: Yes. First, may I say that Mr Saady’s views are probably those of the minority in mid Wales. Indeed, one petition had a few hundred signatures and one had more than 5,000. So, although we are looking at the two together, the vast majority of people support the bypass. However, I think that Mr Saady’s views are also valid because some of his ideas need to be adopted as well as the bypass. That is worth pointing out as well. Obviously, the Newtown bypass has been subject to continuous delays since it was first put in the trunk road forward programme. I think that people will now want a timetable for that programme and to know when the construction phase will start. It would be useful if you could outline that. Most importantly, the many thousands of people who signed the petition probably want to know when the first car will drive onto that new bypass. That is the bottom line. If he could detail a timetable, I would appreciate that.

 

 
10.45 a.m.

 

 
[206]       Carl Sargeant: You will be aware of the reprioritisation within the national transport plan regarding my actions on the Newtown bypass. The provisional start date for publication of the orders is in that proposal, which is 2012-13. Beyond that, it would be wrong of me to make any further discussion points on the Newtown bypass, on the basis that I have made my decision to pursue this proposal and have indicated when I will be laying the orders for discussion. Subject to the detail of the letter that you have there, all residents and all people will have the opportunity, subject to a public inquiry and publishing the orders, to express their views in either direction. From that, I will make a decision on the scheme, subject to a public inquiry, without prejudice. I do not want to be accused of prejudicing my decision at this early stage. My commitment to the scheme has been clearly mapped out in the national transport plan.

 

 
[207]       William Powell: Thank you for setting out the context of the procedure that we need to follow. Colleagues have areas that they want to pursue, but it may be safer to move on to the other issue—which we have considered for some time—of petition P-02-162. It is about road safety concerns on the A40 in Llanspyddid, just outside Brecon. Bethan, I believe that you want to lead on this—

 

 
[208]       Russell George: Sorry, Chair, are we going back to the Newtown issue? There were some other questions—

 

 
[209]       Carl Sargeant: On the Newtown bypass, I have made my decision-making process for the future clear. I would not want to compromise that. I am happy, subject to some of your questions, to discuss issues around the other petition that you have on traffic congestion and the roundabout.

 

 
[210]       William Powell: Sorry, I misinterpreted and was being overcautious. Joyce, you have the green light to go back to planning.

 

 
[211]       Joyce Watson: It is the red lights that are stopping the traffic. [Laughter.]

 

 
[212]       Happy new year, Minister. You issued a letter dated 29 July last year, saying that discussions with residents and other observations suggest that the new signalling system in the town is working well. Could you elaborate on that?

 

 
[213]       Carl Sargeant: I would like to think that I operate in an open and transparent manner, and that when we get things wrong, we should say so. When the lights were installed, they were not working effectively. I asked my team to look at that closely. We remodelled and—what is the technical term for what you do to the lights to realign them?

 

 
[214]       Mr Davies: Recalibrate.

 

 
[215]       Carl Sargeant: The lights have been recalibrated. We believe that there has been a marked difference in the way that traffic flows through Newtown. However, we also believe that the Newtown bypass solution would bring enhanced benefits to the Newtown area. Subject to my decision, we believe that there would be ongoing benefits to a Newtown bypass—should it happen—and that it will have a direct effect on that junction and the traffic flow through Newtown. We recognise that there was an issue with the lights, but we believe that we have recalibrated them and that there is now an easing of traffic flow through the town.

 

 
[216]       William Powell: To take that a step further, you have indicated that a before-and-after study has been undertaken, comparing past and current congestion levels. Is that study around the recalibration exercise that you have just mentioned?

 

 
[217]       Carl Sargeant: Yes, the modelling study is ongoing, and once we have that data, we will do some scenario simulation, with regard to the computerised signalisation of traffic lights and roundabouts, to see whether any benefit analysis can be taken from the data. I suggest, Chair, that we need a little more time to ensure that we are able to find the right solution, which may be in place after the computerised modelling study. Anecdotally, we have heard arguments from both sides of the fence, with some people saying that the situation is worse, while others are saying that it is better. I want to think that we operate statistically, and so, when I have that modelling study data, I will be happy to share some of it with the committee. I will make my decision on whether we should move to a different style of junction or continue with the current junction, but I will base that decision on the statistical data that I receive from my department.

 

 
[218]       William Powell: It would be helpful for our consideration of both of these petitions to have those data as soon as possible.

 

 
[219]       Russell George: I appreciate your honesty, Minister, about the fact that the new SCOOT system that was introduced is not working as expected. People will appreciate your honesty about that. We are grateful that you will provide that before-and-after study information to the committee to consider once it has been finalised. When you look at that statistical information, will you consider the real feeling that people are avoiding the town and using other routes? So, in looking at that modelling study, please take into account that, yes, traffic has eased, but that it might be as a result of people using other routes. I am pleased that you mentioned that you would be prepared to re-examine that junction. Will you comment on whether you would be prepared to consider putting a trial roundabout back in place—and I say ‘trial’ because that would not involve any great expense—given the feeling that the traffic problems in Newtown were considerably worse after the roundabout was removed? Will you confirm that you will at least consider putting a trial roundabout back in place?

 

 
[220]       Carl Sargeant: I can assure the committee and the Member that, if I believe that congestion could be considerably eased by way of a different model, I will seriously consider an alternative method of providing a different style of junction—whether that be a temporary roundabout or otherwise. What I will not do is pre-empt the statistics that are coming through, because while you suggest that it would not be too expensive, there will be an expense, and I will not act on anecdotal evidence that it would be better. I will base my decision on fact. However, I will seriously consider and pursue any better alternatives.

 

 
[221]       Russell George: When do you expect the before-and-after study to be available to us?

 

 
[222]       Carl Sargeant: I imagine that the data will be completed by next month. We have just had Christmas, when traffic flows are different, so I want to get a complete package that will better inform us on the right decisions as to whether we should or should not make any changes. The expense that could be incurred on the back of a potential bypass solution for Newtown must also be taken into consideration. I am more than happy to share the data with the committee, subject to them being robust and complete. So, when I have the data, I will share them with you.

Potholes!

January 11, 2011

Going about my business this week, like many others, I’ve become more aware of the significant amount of potholes in the Welshpool and Newtown areas.

As repair works to damaged roads now gets underway, it’s time we had a change in road maintenance in Mid Wales and an end to the culture of continuous short-term fixes for potholes. The Welsh Assembly Government should be providing the correct level of finance to councils; we are now in a position where the Council is continually struggling to get on top of these problems.

It is time for the Welsh government to reassess priorities and get us out of this culture of short-term fixes. Rather than being reactive, we must consider earlier intervention and maintenance of our highways.

I am aware that there has been an increased number of vehicles visiting local garages due to damage caused by potholes. In South Wales there has been investment in a preventative road repair scheme. That decision has paid off, the work has proved a huge success, and money has been saved in the long run.


www.newtowntraffic.com and increase in pollution levels

October 28, 2010

It’s been three weeks since I launched the Newtown Transport Petition, today the number of people that had signed up exceeded 2,000. I am really encouraged by the wide support for the campaign.

Jules Hudson who presents the BBC’s Escape to the County programme came over to the petition stand and commented that people will not be escaping to Mid Wales because of the traffic problems!

My aim is to get more than 10,000 people to sign the petition; this week I launched a website that enables people to fill in the petition online. The website allows people to quickly sign the petition and it includes a template letter addressed to the Deputy first minister that can be printed off. We have to continue to exert pressure on the minister.

A route announcement on its own is not enough, we need a start date. The recent announcement by the Minister to build more foot paths to help the current problems is a joke and demonstrates just how much the Assembly Government is out of touch, we need urgent measures to offer some relief to drivers not pedestrians.

A recent document has also shown that pollution levels in parts of Newtown are well above national objective levels. The air monitoring that has taken place over recent years has shown a gradual increase in the levels of nitrogen dioxide along New Road. The figures for the first six months of this year compared to the same period last year shows a large increase.

Since the new traffic layout and management system was put in place, congestion in Newtown has got significantly worse in my view and in the view of the majority of people in the locality. I have been told on a number of occasions by officials that there is no evidence or statistics that shows there is an increase in traffic congestion in Newtown, the figures in the recent report do just that.

Sign the petition at www.newtowntraffic.com


The future is Orange for bypass

October 13, 2010

The Deputy First Minister and Minister for the Economy & Transport, Ieuan Wyn Jones has today announced his preferred route for the Newtown bypass – The Orange route.

His announcement is a real step forward and I especially welcome the news that the orange route has been selected as this was my preferred option. This was the longest route of the three choices and in my opinion would be the most effective.

The announcement did fail to provide vital information on a timetable for a start date through to completion. When will the construction start and what can he do to help the traffic problems in the meantime?

We must not forget that a planned bypass route for Newtown has a 40 year history including a protected route dating back to the 1970’s. We need commitment on dates and a timetable which conveys a strong sense of urgency. This must not be allowed to drift in a sea of bureaucracy. A route announcement on its own is not enough.

Neither will today’s news offer much comfort in the short term to queues of traffic through Newtown. We need immediate measures to offer some relief to the traffic problems without waiting until 2016, a date suggested to me by assembly officials as a completion date.

The number of pledges to my Newtown Transport Petition has now attracted over 1000 names, and that’s in just 5 days. It’s my intention to keep up the pressure on the minister and to continue the Newtown Traffic Petition for improvements at the Kerry road junction including a trial roundabout and to demand an early start date for the bypass.

In summary, this is a real step forward, but we need solutions to the current problems and a start date – We must keep the pressure on!


Ready for Action in Montgomeryshire

August 5, 2010

Last week I was selected as the Conservative Party Candidate to fight next years Welsh Assembly elections in Montgomeryshire.

Over 250 people attended a packed Welshpool town hall last Thursday evening to listen to questions put to myself and two other candidates. The meeting was open to members of the public, you didn’t need to be a party member to attend, and you just needed to be registered to vote in Montgomeryshire.

Interestingly, when former Labour MP John Marek was selected as the Conservative candidate to fight the seat in Wrexham the other day, also one of only three candidates, just 26 people turned up, I would have felt quite disappointed if this was the turnout in Welshpool. That said I of course wish John well and hope that he and I will be working as colleagues next May.

Turnout was high in Montgomershire because all three candidates where local, albeit from different parts of the constituency, and each having friends and family in the community coming out to support. All that said there was much interest, and many with an open mind.

I felt privileged and honored to have been selected. It was a difficult process, when the opposition are also friends who would have made excellent candidates for Montgomeryshire. I am hoping both will have the opportunity as assembly candidates in the other areas.

I had decided that if selected I was intending to fully commit my time to the job of candidate. It is my intention to win next May and to fly the flag for Montgomershire in the Assembly. I am keen to focus on finding solutions to the many problems we face and to listen to peoples concerns.

We need to retain and improve our local services and to find more efficient  ways of delivering services. We need to provide support for local business to combat high unemployment levels. I shall be challenging the Welsh Assembly Government on Montgomeryshire’s poor transport infrastructure, and more importantly on making an announcement on the preferred route and start date for the Newtown Bypass which I believe is crucial to the regeneration of our local economy.

The Welsh Assembly Government has done little for Mid Wales and this needs to change.


Newtown traffic update

March 18, 2010

For background, please read my previous two blog posts (Newtown traffic chaos and Letter to Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones AM regarding Newtown traffic chaos).

I have not yet received an answer to my 26th February letter I sent to Ieuan Wyn Jones. My letter had asked for an urgent traffic safety audit and I understand that this has now taken place and traffic flow has improved. I am however disappointed that Mr Jones has not yet answered my wider questions on detailing the timetable for a by-pass.

At the Newtown Traffic Study exhibition last September, which revealed three options for a Newtown By-Pass, assembly officials informed me that Ieuan Wyn Jones will be revealing the preferred route in January. This has not happened. This is not the time for any slippage. As the Easter holidays approach I am of course concerned about further traffic disruption.

The only solution for Newtown’s traffic problems is a by-pass. I have contacted Mr Jones office again this week and his staff told me that I will get a reply before March 24th, he does seem to not be in touch with what is happening in Newtown.

What we need from Mr Jones is confirmation which option is the preferred route and a timetable for works to begin on the by-pass through to completion of the project.


Letter to Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones AM regarding Newtown traffic chaos

February 26, 2010

26 February 2010

Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones AM
Deputy First Minister and Minister for Economy and Transport
National Assembly for Wales
Cardiff Bay
Cardiff
CF99 1NA

Dear Deputy First Minister,

Traffic chaos

As I am sure you are aware, Newtown has experienced huge traffic problems for many years and, with the opening of Newtown’s Tesco Store on Monday, the problems have become significantly worse. I have been inundated with comments from people talking about their deep concerns over the traffic chaos in Newtown. Police have also received numerous complaints.

There are two issues here: Firstly, the unacceptable design of the new traffic lights system that replaced the Pool Road roundabout. The second issue concerns the failure to synchronise the new system with other traffic lights through the town as was proposed.

To most motorists a green light means ‘go’ and the current layout is causing confusion on priority. There has already been a number of minor bumps and this must now be considered as a major accident waiting to happen. I’ve never before seen a four-way junction without filter lanes. I am now calling on you to undertake an urgent independent road safety audit.

Your Department is responsible for this trunk road. It’s your Department that approved the removal of the roundabout and the layout and design of the new traffic lights.

I was told today that the Assembly’s experiences elsewhere indicates that traffic flows will improve as drivers become familiar with the new layout and that Welsh Assembly Government does not intend therefore to make any fundamental changes immediately. I accept that flow will improve a little as drivers get used to the layout, but do not accept that the people of Newtown will have to wait to see if the problems fix themselves; we need action now. Your department does not seem in touch with what is happening here in Newtown.

I also understand that the software that will synchronise the signals through Newtown will be installed at the beginning of next week, and your department is anticipating that flows will be further improved as signal operation is optimised during the week. Unfortunately, I don’t have the same degree of confidence.

The current chaos is causing huge damage to the local economy and the wider Mid Wales community. Businesses to the West of Newtown are suffering the most. Newtown is a central point in Wales but even businesses as far away as Aberystwyth may be affected by this mess. Running a business in Mid Wales is tough enough already. The last thing we need is a new traffic layout which makes things a whole lot worse. It’s just not good enough to say that the problems may be fixed in two or three weeks, it should be fixed now. Your Department is responsible and accountable for this completely unacceptable situation.

I would therefore request an urgent reply from you, setting out your plans to resolve the unacceptable layout at the new set of traffic lights and your assurances that the new synchronised signals system through Newtown will be an improvement on traffic flow from 12 months ago.

At the Newtown Traffic Study exhibition last September, which revealed three options for a Newtown By-Pass, your department informed me that you would be revealing the preferred route in January. This has not happened. I have submitted my response to the consultation in which I gave my support for the Orange Route Variant 1.

I should be further grateful if you could now confirm which option is the preferred route and set out the timetable for works to begin on the By-Pass through to completion of the project.

Yours faithfully,

Russell George
Cynghorydd Sir / County Councillor – Newtown Central
Office: 01686 626500
Mobile: 07867782727


Newtown traffic chaos

February 25, 2010

As you can imagine I’ve been inundated with comments from people talking about their deep concerns over the traffic chaos in Newtown. Police have also received numerous complaints.

There are two issues here, the first is the unacceptable design of the new traffic lights system that replaced the Pool Road roundabout, and the second is the failure to date to synchronise the new system with other traffic lights thought the town as was proposed.

To most motorists a green light means go and the current layout is causing confusion on priority. There has already been a number of minor bumps and this must now be considered as a major accident waiting to happen. I’ve never before seen a four way junction without filter lanes. Along with other Newtown Councillors I demanded that an independent road safety audit be carried out urgently.

The County Times has reported that the Council are blaming Tesco.  Planning conditions required that before the store can open, all the traffic works must be completed and tested to the Planning Authority’s satisfaction.

Personally, although I think a degree of blame should be placed with Tesco, I believe the major part  should to directed towards WAG, after all, they are responsible for the trunk road, the Assembly department approved the removal of the roundabout and the layout and design of the new traffic lights.

I was told today that the Assembly’s experiences elsewhere  indicates that traffic flows will improve as drivers become familiar with the new layout and that WAG does not intend therefore to make any fundamental changes immediately. I accept that flow will improve a little as drivers get used to the layout, but WAG are just not in touch with what is happening here in Newtown and are making excuses.

I also understand that the software that will synchronise the signals through Newtown will be installed at the beginning of next week, the WAG are anticipating that flows will be further improved as signal operation is optimised during the week, unfortunately, I don’t have the same degree of confidence .

The current chaos is causing huge damage to the local economy and the wider Mid Wales community. Businesses to the West of Newtown are suffering the most.  Newtown is a central point in Wales but even businesses as far away as Aberystwyth may be effected by this mess.  Running a business in Mid Wales is tough enough already.  The last thing we need is a new traffic layout which makes things a whole lot worse. Its just not good enough to say that the problems may be fixed in two or three weeks, It should be fixed now. WAG must be held accountable for this completely unacceptable situation. Tesco consultants and the WAG will have to come up with better solutions and fast.


Orange route it should be

January 7, 2010

Since I was elected in 2008, Lobbying for a Bypass for Newtown has been a priority.

I want to give an update on progress and I have also outlined  my response to the Newtown Transport Study, submitted to The Welsh Assembly Government.

March – Nick Bourne AM, Leader of the Opposition in the Welsh Assembly accepted my invitation to come to Newtown last year. I took Nick, by car through Newtown and along Llanidloes road at peak time. He fully accepted a Bypass is urgently needed and backed my campaign.

July – I had an opportunity to talk directly to Ieuan Wyn Jones, Deputy First Minister responsible for Transport, I expressed to him the strong views of the people of Newtown.

September – The Newtown Transport study was published and the Welsh Assembly Government at last committed to a Bypass for Newtown. Some of you may have visited the “Newtown Transport study” at the Monty Club last year, which detailed three choices for a proposed route.

November – All members of the public where able to respond to the consultation. In my own response I made my view clear that the Orange option is by far the best. The Brown option passes through Mochdre industrial estate, and even with adaption’s, would still have too many turning and crossing movements. The Purple route is just too close to residential estates.

I detail below my response to the Newtown Transport Study submitted to The Welsh Assembly Government. As a Newtown member of Powys County Council, I was also involved in the official consultation response from the Council. My own response and that submitted by the Powys County Council are very similar.

Newtown Transport Study

Response to Public Consultation Exhibitions, September 2009

from Cllr Russell George, Newtown Central Ward

1.      I fully support and prefer the proposed Orange route – variant 1 which whilst being the longest option, is considered to be far more effective as a bypass to Newtown. The variant also incorporates appropriate on-line improvements to the existing road network, together with improved cycling, walking facilities and access, which will enhance health and well being and sustainability, and ensure reliable journey times for public transport and residents and visitors to the town.

2.      From an economic and regeneration view point the Orange route – variant 1 provides an effective bypass for through traffic and because of the extended length generally avoids a mix of local and long distance traffic. It will therefore encourage investment in Newtown and the sounding areas,  reducing congestion and delays. The bypass will also improve safety and resilience on the trunk road network and provide reliable journey times.

3.      The Orange route – variant 1 will also greatly improve transport links between the West Midlands and Aberystwyth which is identified as a key settlement of national significance in the Wales Spacial Plan, and will encourage investment, provide employment opportunities and safeguard jobs in Mid Wales.

4.      In fully supporting the by-pass proposals I would emphasis the need to ensure that signing for tourists and visitors to Newtown at the bypass connections with the existing trunk road network should be positive and should encourage drivers to divert into the town for tourist attractions and services. It is therefore imperative that a signing strategy incorporating the bypassed community should be implemented irrespective of the route eventually chosen in order to reduce disbenefit to businesses along the old route due to reduced through traffic.

5.      I would also drew attention to the lack of overtaking opportunities for drivers on trunk roads approaching Newtown, which coupled with the high volumes of traffic and HGVs leads to driver frustration and compromises highway safety. I also have the view that the opportunity to provide overtaking by designing and construction a bypass utilising 2+1 traffic lanes should not be discounted because of additional cost and land acquisition. It is considered that the costs associated with fatal and serious incidents on the surrounding road networks more than cover any additional cost of providing safe, well signed overtaking facilities.

6.      In supporting Orange route – variant 1, it would be worthwhile connecting the Mochdre Industrial estate road via an underbridge to the existing A483, between the junction of the A483 and middle Dolfor road, and the proposed lower Dolfor road underbridge. The formation of a roundabout at this location would cater for the four road connections and would remove the existing severe bend on the A483 near the property known as Ashbrook.

7.      Flooding of properties and streets in Newtown from the large open and culverted watercourse which runs alongside the A483 Dolfor Road has occurred on a number of occasions. The watercourse will be affected by construction of the bypass and I suggest the inclusion of an attenuation pond perhaps in conjunction with a roundabout would significantly reduce the flooding risk and would also cater for drainage for the new roads.

8.      Turning to the alternative routes, I am of the view that the Brown option which passes through Mochdre industrial estate would not provide an effective bypass. The existing road has numerous accesses and junctions and whilst these could be rationalised, too many turning and crossing movements would remain. Given the likely pedestrian usage signal controlled crossings would be necessary together with footways other uncontrolled crossing points in order to link the industrial units. The inclusion of an appropriate speed limit and enforcement would also be required to secure highway safety.  The route would be used by public transport serving the estate and would require public transport stops. All such measures would reduce the effectiveness of the route as a bypass.

9.      I consider that whilst the Purple option follows the line of the original protected route, significant development has take place on land adjoining the route during the intervening period. As a result the proposed route is now too close to residential estates and a school for children with special education needs. It is acknowledged that mitigation measures can be undertaken to reduce noise and light pollution but the proximity of the residential properties to the road means that residents will inevitably experience a reduction in air quality and some degree of noise and vibration. These disbenefits may be exacerbated by regular use of the route by wind farm development traffic over a long period.

10.    It is understood that children attending the school are particularly susceptible to traffic noise and vibrations and as the proposed route utilises part of the school playing field it is unlikely that the social and environmental effects of passing traffic could be mitigated at this location.

11.    I also express concern regarding the proximity of the proposed Purple route to the residential estates in terms of security and safety. The existing green open space is currently used by children as an unofficial play area and whilst the bypass would be securely fenced, there is a possibility that children would risk crossing the high speed road to continue to access play areas. Similarly, unofficial footpaths connect the residential estates with Mochdre industrial estate and it is likely that pedestrians would force additional unauthorised crossing of the bypass route, despite the provision of a footbridge.

12.    I fully support the Variant 1 option irrespective of the route chosen, but I also have an aspiration to see walking and cycling facilities along the whole length of the A483 and A489 in Newtown to link with existing safe routes in the community. This may involve single lane priority working at both Dolfor and Nant Oer railway bridges in order to provide adequate footway/cycleway width. It may also require the widening of footways and shared use along Llanidloes Road, New Road and Pool Road.

13.    With regard to Rail, I fully support any proposals to enhance facilities at the rail station including parking and links with the Traws-Cambria bus service. Also, any improvement in cycling and walking, and public transport links between the existing bus interchange in the centre of Newtown and the train station are welcome.

14.    In conclusion, I believe a Bypass for Newtown is long overdue. I welcome and endorse the proposals and confirm full support for Orange route – variant 1.


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,289 other followers